Episode 49 – We’ve both seen The Princess Bride
What can we say that hasn't already been said? A true classic, starring...
Episode 48 – Our First Time Watching Sophie’s Choice
And yes, that's the title of the film, based on a book by...
Episode 47 – Our first time watching Re-Animator
With a “Mary Shelley meets Alfred Hitchcock” vibe, this Frankenstein story equal parts...
Episode 46 – Our first time watching The Toxic Avenger
We were overdue for an 80s cult classic. One of those “it's so...
Episode 45 – Billie’s first time watching The Witches of Eastwick
Based on the book by John Updike, this 80s classic stars our main...
Episode 44 – Our first time watching Red Dawn
A “hypothetical WWIII” movie, we weren't sure what to expect. All we knew...
Episode 43 – Sophie’s first time watching Top Gun
“I feel the need, the need for speed!” For real, Sophie has never...
Episode 42 – Our first time watching The Outsiders
What happens when two sisters watch different versions of a movie they've never...